Welcome to Carrots! I'm so glad you're here. This is where I share thoughts on liturgical living, faith, parenting, culture, and an extra dose of Jane Austen. You can sign up for my email newsletter here to stay in touch, or look me up on Instagram!
This is a guest post by my dear friend Kaitlin of More Like Mary~More Like Me. in the Women Speak on NFP series. In this series you will hear from women using various methods of NFP, some to avoid pregnancy, some trying to conceive, and their experiences.
Disclaimer: This series is not meant to be a substitute for any method of training in NFP! If you are interested in one of the methods introduced in this series, please contact a certified instructor for information about training in that method of NFP.
My experience with NFP has been different than most. I’m coming up on five years of marriage to my husband, Ted, and we’ve yet to actually use NFP to avoid a pregnancy. Because of my history, we knew we might have trouble conceiving and started trying for a baby pretty much from the get-go. Even though we haven’t needed to chart to postpone getting pregnant, we are eternally grateful for the knowledge that came with our pre-marriage NFP courses. NFP led us to NaPro technology, a technology that uses a woman’s NFP charts to direct its diagnoses and treatments for infertility.
We have NFP (and NaPro) to thank for getting us pregnant. Here’s how:
1. NFP helps to identify key days of your cycle to make diagnostic testing and treatment more accurate. One example: Anyone who has gone through the initial rounds of testing for infertility has probably heard of “day 21 blood work”. In theory, day 21 is one week after ovulation and a good time to check your hormone levels to get an idea of what your body is doing. This is based on the idea that women have 28 day cycles and ovulate on day 14. But, last I checked, a woman who has 28 day cycles 100% of the time….. doesn’t really exist. So if you ovulate a few days later than the doctor thinks you “should”, your blood work could be horribly inaccurate and even misleading. A much better approach is to complete the blood work on “peak + 7”. That is to say, seven days after you identify your “peak” which is ovulation. If you don’t chart, you can’t identify this crucial time and complete the blood work with this level of accuracy.
The first OB we sought help from when we realized we couldn’t get pregnant was not trained in NaPro. He suggested the “day 21 blood work” and an ultrasound series on days 12, 14, and 16 to watch my follicles grow, hopefully erupt, and produce an egg. We opted to do the blood work (and paid thousands of dollars out of pocket. Don’t even get me started on that….) but weren’t able to do the ultrasound series. He ended up putting me on a high risk medication for a hormone level he thought was too high. When I was tested by a NaPro doc on “peak + 7” months later, it was perfectly normal and the medication wasn’t needed. I’m thankful we didn’t do the ultrasound series because if I didn’t ovulate on the exact days he thought I would, it could have been a complete waste of time.
We did several ultrasound series with our NaPro doctor a year later and discovered I wasn’t ovulating. Thanks to my charts, we were able to identify the best days for me to take a medication that helped with this. We then used my charts to identify my peak and watch my follicles grow in order to determine if more medication was needed. We have NFP to thank for giving us this amazing picture:
Three follicles. All of which erupted later that day. One of which released the egg that held half the DNA for her
who has known grown into this.
Amazing.
2. NFP helps doctors heal your body rather than just get you pregnant. I think that many doctors, in their quest to “get you pregnant” really miss an opportunity to get you pregnant.
Let me back up first.
I saw my first OB when I was 15 years old. I had horrible, horrible, horrible periods that were causing me to miss school every month. Cramps that sent me to the floor in agony. Puking for the first several days of my cycle. I saw just about every OB our small town had to offer and they all said the exact. same. thing. They all suggested I take the pill. It sounded like a great idea to me…except my mom refused to let me. My long term boyfriend probably had something to do with her refusal, but all I could see at 15 was her refusing to let me feel better. “This is the only thing that will help me!” I argued. She finally consented when I was 18 and my cramps instantly went away. But after only a few months I began to wonder what I was actually putting into my body every day. Even more so, I began to wonder what this meant for my future. I knew I wanted children, so what was going to happen to me when I went off the pill? I came to realize that I wasn’t healed, I was patched. And I desperately wanted to be healed.
As a sophomore in college, I sought out our local NFP instructor and asked her if she knew of any doctors who would treat me without prescribing the pill. She knew of one, several hours away, and I called immediately. The office said I had to learn NFP before meeting with him so he could review my charts. So I signed up for the class and took it with a friend who was having similar issues. After a few months, I met with my first NaPro doctor, told him about my symptoms, and showed him my charts.
Endometriosis.
Not yet a diagnosis, but a strong suspicion. He suggested surgery.
I cried and cried. In part because I was worried about what this meant for a future family (Ted and I were newly dating but pretty serious at this point). But I also cried tears of joy and relief. Finally, after five years and countless doctors, I had one who was actually going to try to help. He even gave me this analogy. “If your car breaks down, you don’t call a tow truck to tow you around in a broken car forever. You call a mechanic and get it fixed. Birth control is just a tow truck. I want to actually fix your car.”
Cut forward a few years when Ted and I are seeking help for infertility. Our blood work experience has already taught us to only work with doctors trained in NaPro, but we needed to meet with a local OB to arrange for ultrasounds to be sent to our doctor. (He was three hours away. NaPro is worth. the. drive.) I started to tell the OB just a tad about my history and was about to ask him if he would simply order ultrasounds for me and let us use his technician when he interrupted me. “It looks like, with your history, you’re going to need In-Vitro. I highly doubt you’ll ever get pregnant on your own.” I told him that, as a Catholic, that was not a moral option and not something I wanted to do. He just restated his stupid opinion and acted like I was crazy. He did consent to ordering the ultrasounds, however, which was all we needed from him.
A year later, after his technician conducted our ultrasound series and our NaPro doctor prescribed the right medicine, I gave birth to our beautiful daughter just two hours before Dr. In-Vitro went on call. If she had been born just a bit later he would have been the doctor catching her. I was actually disappointed it didn’t work out that way. I would have loved to have had the opportunity to look him the eye and say, “Remember me?“. Don’t think I wouldn’t have done it.
Because I had a doctor who understood NFP and was able to read my charts, he never once suggested that I wasn’t able to get pregnant without artificial reproductive technology. He fixed the problem. He healed my body. And he gave us our Hannah.
3. NFP helps you identify the best possible days for conception. If you’ve been following Haley’s series, you are aware of the fact that you can use NFP to avoid pregnancy by avoiding sex on certain days. But you can also increase your chances of getting pregnant by having lots of sex at the right times!
Anyone who has dealt with infertility knows that’s not nearly as fun as it sounds.
Nuff said?
4. NFP treats the whole person. We are body and soul. We cannot find healing in a system of medicine that only seeks to treat our body. When I sought out doctors who were committed to treating me with NFP and NaPro technology I found doctors who truly cared about me. I’ve worked with four different NFP only doctors in three different states and each of them has helped me deal with the spiritual and emotional aspects of infertility just as much as the physical. One doctor told me of his prayers for me the morning of my first surgery. Another allowed Ted to bless his hands with holy water before going in for surgery a second time. Each of them took the time to fully explain things to me, allowed me time to process and grieve, offered me tissues, and assured me of their prayers. I’m not saying you can’t also find that in mainstream medicine, but holy doctors seem to abound the world of NaPro. And the world needs holy doctors to treat more than just medical conditions.
NFP is powerful. It’s information that every women deserves to have about her body. Especially women struggling to get pregnant.
That’s real medicine. That’s what got me pregnant.
Beautiful! Thanks for sharing this, Kaitlin! What a great testimony to how Catholics embrace science right along with Faith – the two are not at odds, but in harmony!
Your daughter is so cute. I’m very happy for you!
Love Katilin, love this post! Another great one to share!
So inspiring Kaitlin! Love following your journey through motherhood! I have a coworker who spent thousands of dollars and many years of time on IVF (20 years ago) and it never worked for her. She now has three beautiful adopted Russian children, but it breaks my heart to hear what she had to go through. It brings such joy to hear of successful NaPro stories! I mention it to everyone I know who says anything about infertility – could you imagine if it were as common as IVF?!?
I have thought that so many times. If only everyone knew how much better it is than IVF! More effective too!
Thanks for your story, Kaitlin! I loved the way you put it: “I came to realize that I wasn’t healed, I was patched.” That’s EXACTLY what it is when people go on the Pill to “fix” their menstrual problems.
I’m a huge advocate for NaPro, too. While I did manage to get pregnant naturally just before I was able to see my NaPro doctor, I really believe in what they do and have two friends who were able to conceive with their help. I can’t think of a single good story connected to conventional fertility treatment. Thank God for Dr. Hilgers!
Thank you very much for sharing your encouraging story! I am Catholic and recently engaged, so this series about NFP came along at the perfect time!
Like you, Kaitlin, I received a diagnosis in college that often results in infertility. I have seen several mainstream doctors about this problem and even some who are a little ‘off the beaten path’ (though none were familiar with NFP) with little to no improvement.
So, if it is not too indiscreet to ask, I’d like to ask whether in your experience NFP doctors prescribe bio-identical hormones or mainstream medications– or both?
I cannot be sure, the drugs I needed were mainstream but administered with a NaPro approach. However, I know NaPro doctors typically use bio-identical progesterone (I think!) rather than the other stuff. There is also a big difference with how NaPro treats thyroid issues. Sorry I can’t help more-but I can put you in touch with people who can if you’d like!
You answered my question perfectly! Thank you!
Love this post and love your heart, Kaitlin. Happy, happy!
I am so grateful today for blogs allowing me to share in these wonderful stories about conception. I wish there was something like this when I first had infertility issues in 1968. I was without a second baby for 20 years, until surgery for a very painful ovarian cyst. In those days (1986) it was exploratory surgery that found it, sonogram technology wasn’t that good. My wonderful sons are 20 years apart, and my daughter is now 23. The doctors told me that the cyst was not part of the infertility issue, still I was pregnant just two months after the surgery. I am sending prayers to you Haley, and to you too Kaitlin.
You are right-I am beyond grateful for my online support community!
I actually was able to use my charting to prove to a doctor that I didn’t have Endometriosis (though I had a positive biopsy after my c-section). Because of my charts she now believe that it was a rather benign patch of tissue and cannot believe I actually have the disease. I spent months believing hte original diagnosis before I got the courage to say “but look at these charts and rest of my (non) symptoms”.
Thank you, Kaitlin! Your daughter is beautiful! This story filled my heart today.
Loving this series! Thank you for publishing it.
Yes, yes, yes! I love everything about this article. I wish more women could see what you are talking about with patching vs. actually fixing the problem. Who is actually going to heal the problem–the IVF doctor, or the physician trained in NaPro Technology? Thanks for sharing your story, Kaitlin, and thank you for “hosting” all of these wonderful stories, Haley!
As the wife of a NFP OB/GYN, thank you SO much for this testimony!
Love this! So beautifully written. My favorite line (He was three hours away. NaPro is worth. the. drive.) This story so wonderfully shows NaPro in action. Thank you for sharing!
Yes! It breaks my heart when women settle for less because the nearest doctor is a few hours away. It is WORTH it!
I am really enjoying this series, but this post hit close to home. I suffered from infertility for the first nine years of marriage. I got really good at charting, cervical mucus and the like. No amount of, nor timing of sex was able to help us. I’m Mormon, and we don’t have any problems with help from IVF, and, yes, it DID fix my problem. It gave me the miracle of a son just before my tenth wedding anniversary.
Just to be clear, it wasn’t the charting and timing that got us pregnant. It was the medicine and surgeries and ultrasounds. NFP only served to make these things more effective. I hope my post didn’t come across as saying that only using NFP helped us overcome our infertility.
What a testament!
We’ve been trying to conceive for 18 months now, using sympto-thermal NFP (and we just switched to Creighton so we can get help from a NaPro).
I remember when I realized that a NaPro was so close to our home town (so close being 1.5 hours!) and talking with the Creighton instructor to set up our initial intro session. I felt such… hope. I still feel it.
I know that it may not be easy for us, even now, but the feeling that someone is “with” us in this- that I have people there who support my beliefs and decisions and actually want to figure out what the issue is and then heal it- it’s taken so much pressure off of me already.
Beautiful post. Her story is a lot like mine. Unable to conceive for 3 years, diagnosed with endometriosis with the help of Creighton/Napro, successful surgery with a positive pregnancy test a few months later. Now we’re happily expecting baby #2. I’m so glad to see people acknowledging that NFP is not all about spacing or avoiding pregnancies.
Hi,
I know it’s an old post but I always have to respond when I see these posts about NaproTech.
The correct medical specialist to see about infertility is not an OBGYN. An OB treats women after they become pregnant. The specialist to see is called a Reproductive Endocrinologist. Your OB thought you would need IVF because getting women pregnant is not what he is trained to do.
NaproTech is NOT more effective than conventional infertility treatment. It is more efficient than IVF – but that’s because only a small percentage of infertile people wind up needing IVF in a conventional setting. The worst cases. You can’t accurately compare the 2 patient groups.
For an accurate look at IVF itself you can examine donor egg IVF. Many doctors achieve live birth rates of 70-80% per cycle with IVF and donor eggs. Much better than Napro.
The problem with IVF isn’t that it doesn’t work, it’s the ethics of it.
There is literally nothing in the Napro arsenal that a conventional RE doesn’t do. Ovarian drilling, surgery for endo, progesterone support, tracking a cycle hormonally, injection meds (I assume you were on one of the injectables). This is what makes me cringe when I read about people driving hours to see a Napro doctor. You’re driving hours and the main difference you’re getting is that the doctor has a crucifix on the wall.
Thank you! Thank you! Thank you for this post. We practiced NFP for years, had stahe 3 endometriosis and almost had to have a hysterectomy because of it. It has been 9 yeara now and still no baby and we have been open to life. My husband and I had talked about NaPro but have essentially given up. I havent been satisfied with any of my doctors in the past five years and this helps me to want to seek out a NaPro specialist in our area. When I had it the past, it was about a six month wait. I think I’ll look into it for my next appiintment.
We have given up, but I may at least have a doctor that can help me be more comfortable.