Carrots for Michaelmas

Cultivating a Catholic family through literature, liturgical living, and urban homesteading

Follow Carrots!

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • About
    • About Haley
    • Advertise
    • Privacy
  • My Books
    • The Grace of Enough
    • The Literary Medicine Cabinet
    • Liturgical Year eCookbooks
  • Faith & Liturgical Living
    • Our Conversion Story
    • Catholicism
      • Saints
        • St. Anne
        • St. Anthony of Padua
        • St. Anthony of the Desert
        • St. Benedict of Nursia
        • St. Brigid
        • St. Dominic
        • St. Joachim
        • St. Lucy
        • St. Patrick
        • St. Scholastica
      • Christian Year
        • Advent
        • Christmas
        • Epiphany
        • Lent
        • Mardi Gras
        • Easter
  • Family & Homesteading
    • Birth
    • Children
    • DIY
    • Finances
    • Homeschooling
    • Marriage
    • NFP
    • Our Home
  • Bookishness
    • Blog
    • Book Lists
  • Fashion
  • Podcast
    • Episodes
  • Speaking

Harry Potter, Dumbledore’s Mercy, and the Triumph of the Holy Cross

September 14, 2014 By Haley 20 Comments

Welcome to Carrots! I'm so glad you're here. This is where I share thoughts on liturgical living, faith, parenting, culture, and an extra dose of Jane Austen. You can sign up for my email newsletter here to stay in touch, or look me up on Instagram!

Welcome to Carrots! I'm so glad you're back. You can sign up for my email newsletter here to stay in touch, or look me up on Instagram!

Harry Potter, Dumbledore's Mercy, and the Upside Down Power of God's Love // Carrots for Michaelmas

It’s the Feast of the Triumph of the Holy Cross. What does that have to do with Harry Potter? I don’t try to hide the fact that I’m a Harry Potter fangirl. I’m often reflecting on the plot and themes, whether kids should read the series, and how Molly Weasley is fantastic.

(SPOILER ALERT: Do not continue if you haven’t completed the series.)

One of the most memorable scenes in the series depicts the last moments of Hogwarts Headmaster, Albus Dumbledore’s life. He arrives at the tallest tower of the Hogwarts castle in a weakened state when a boy–Harry’s nemesis, Draco Malfoy–arrives on the scene with the intent to murder him. Harry helplessly watches the whole exchange. Dumbledore has frozen him so that he cannot interfere and be in danger.

Dumbledore’s attitude is remarkable. He does not seem afraid or threatened. He begins talking to Draco in a way that is not only dignified but offers dignity to his would-be killer.

At one point Draco comments, “You’re in my power…I’m the one with the wand…You are at my mercy.” And indeed, it appears that way. Dumbledore has been disarmed. He is weak. And a healthy young man is pointing a wand at him with the intent to kill.

But Dumbledore responds in a surprisingly way: “No, Draco. It is my mercy, not yours, that matters now.”

What a strange thing for a powerless man to say! But is it strange? Perhaps the real problem is that we misunderstand the meaning of true power.

In modern fantasy, this theme of self-sacrifice conquering the most powerful foes comes up again and again. In The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe by C. S. Lewis, the White Witch foolishly thinks she can conquer the lion Aslan by killing him. Her obsession with power makes it impossible for her to comprehend that death is no match for the deep and ancient magic of sacrificial love Aslan will awaken when he lays down his life for those he loves. When things seem most hopeless, love turns the tables (or in this case, the table is broken by the power of love).

Tolkien’s weak little hobbits begin a quest that seems so foolhardy that it’s barely noticed by the evil Sauron who seeks to destroy all they love–but despite all odds, friendship, courage, and love are stronger than armies of orcs. And the mercy of Frodo toward the undeserving Gollum, results in the salvation of Middle-earth.

And here in Rowling’s world, we have Dumbledore patiently trying to explain to Draco that power lies in sacrifice, love, and mercy, not in a well-aimed weapon.

All of these stories make me think of The Story, the cosmic story: God’s love for humanity is victorious at just the moment when hope is almost gone. There is God himself on the Cross. Powerless, weak, being executed at our demand. Jesus is in our power. In the hands of a broken humanity that would rather kill God than face our need for Him. He is at our mercy.

But it is his mercy that matters now. “Father, forgive them. They know not what they do.” We call for his blood, and he pours it out over our heads, not to condemn us, but to heal us and wash us clean. He is the one with the power, because his love surpasses death. Because his death redeems his killers. Holy victim. Spotless victim. Christ the King.

It is His mercy that matters now. And He offers it to us with arms open wide, nailed by us to the Cross, yet ready to embrace us if only we will run to him.

Harry Potter, Dumbledore's Mercy, and the Upside Down Power of God's Love // Carrots for Michaelmas

image 1: Michael J. Bennett (Own work) [CC-BY-SA-3.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0)], via Wikimedia Commons

image 2:© Jorge Royan / http://www.royan.com.ar / CC-BY-SA-3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Related Posts

  • What Harry Potter Teaches Us About Confronting Death with Hope and the Glorious Communion of Saints!Hallowmas with Harry: What Harry Potter Taught Me About Death and the Communion of Saints
  • Is Your Favorite Saint a Gryffindor? The Definite Guide to Sorting the Saints!Is Your Favorite Saint a Gryffindor? The Definitive Guide to Sorting the Saints
  • Why You Needn't Bother with Harry Potter and the Cursed ChildWhy You Needn't Bother with Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

Filed Under: Bookishness, Catholicism Tagged With: c.s. lewis, faith, Harry Potter, love, mercy, narnia, rowling, tolkien

Comments

  1. Arenda says

    September 14, 2014 at 2:32 pm

    Beautifully said!

    Reply
    • Haley says

      September 15, 2014 at 8:25 am

      Thank you, Arenda!

      Reply
  2. Hannah says

    September 14, 2014 at 3:49 pm

    Haley, I love your posts. This is what it’s all about! You have such a gift for blogging (particularly on the HP subject matter and how we can view it as Catholics). I (and I’m sure so many others) wish I lived on your street and we could meet for coffee at least once a week and discuss books, theology, and of course, Harry Potter!
    You are an inspiring blogger with a lot of spark in your writing, and I’m so happy to be a part of your readership.

    Reply
    • Haley says

      September 15, 2014 at 8:39 am

      Aw, thanks Hannah! That is so kind. And I would love weekly coffee dates 😉

      Reply
  3. Karen Edmisten says

    September 14, 2014 at 5:19 pm

    Lovely, Haley.

    Reply
    • Haley says

      September 15, 2014 at 8:39 am

      Thank you, Karen! That means a lot coming from such a lovely writer. <3

      Reply
  4. Charlotte says

    September 14, 2014 at 8:54 pm

    This is great. My friends and I just decided we were going to read the HP series and actually think while reading it (we all feel like we haven’t been learning from the books we read since high school, when it was required to think critically and have discussions…). I’m going to share this with them!

    Reply
    • Haley says

      September 15, 2014 at 8:40 am

      Reading thoughtfully for fun is the best! Thanks for sharing the post 😉

      Reply
  5. ladyjane says

    September 14, 2014 at 9:11 pm

    I LOVE this! I love HP & it’s so wonderful to see posts which relate it to our Faith.

    Reply
    • Haley says

      September 15, 2014 at 8:40 am

      Thank you so much!

      Reply
  6. Cathy says

    September 15, 2014 at 9:42 am

    Great post. I’m a fairly new reader, so forgive me if this is something you’ve already covered, but have you ever read “Baptizing Harry Potter” by Luke Bell? Great take on all the Christian and Catholic symbolism in the book series. Made me go back and reread (again) the whole series in a whole new light.

    Reply
  7. Willow says

    September 15, 2014 at 2:25 pm

    Wow. Beautifully said. I love how you drew your examples from high fantasy old and new(ish). I also really love pointing out how many Christian themes can be found in the books when some people were/are intent on decrying it as satanic or evil (the books were banned in my private elementary and middle school right at the onset of Potter mania). Really great post.

    Reply
  8. deltaflute says

    September 16, 2014 at 11:25 am

    One of the reasons JK Rowling said she withheld her religious beliefs (Christian) in the beginning was because she said if she revealed them, people would be able to figure out her books too easily. Basically the series is Christian-based morality. So I’m betting the scene of Dumbledore acting Christ-like was exactly what she had in mind.

    Awesome post!

    Reply
  9. Shauna says

    September 20, 2014 at 11:54 pm

    Beautiful post! I just finished reading the Harry Potter series aloud to my 10 year old boys and I was struck time and time again by the redemptive messages I found throughout, much like you mention here. In the last book I think I actually gasped out loud and shouted “like the communion of saints” when Harry found the resurrection stone and his loved ones accompanied him on his sacrificial journey.

    Reply
  10. Fr. Isaiah Mary OP says

    September 29, 2014 at 2:08 pm

    Thanks for this post! This reflection reveals well the richness of JKR’s work.

    What does power mean? What does mercy mean? What is love and sacrifice? Your reflection is insightful and concise.

    Being a potterhead myself, I have occasionally used the series to illuminate the deepest truths of Christianity, with mixed results.

    Thank you for this!

    Reply
  11. Jenn says

    February 14, 2016 at 10:04 pm

    I’m coming to this post late, but I’m a fellow Catholic and Harry Potter fan. The message of Mercy is so strong in these books. I tell my kids who’ve been allowed to read to #7 that the most important line in the whole series is when Harry tells Volemort to try for a little remorse. Being sorry for what he had done would have made all the difference. It made me a bit sad that they skipped that part in the movie, because it means that there are so many people who didn’t see the importance of it. There’s so much to unpack in these books :-).

    Reply
  12. Diana says

    September 15, 2016 at 1:14 am

    I love your reflections on Harry Potter. I’ve read the first story to my six year old. And she’s watched a few of the movies and heard the first two stories on audiobooks. We play pretend Harry Potter too. And I refer to it quite frequently as a way to show how the Christian life can be lived out. Just the other day, we were walking home talking about worst things that could happen. She said that death was the worst thing. I said there are things worth than death. She immediately connected it to “not knowing love” like Voldemort. It was pretty amazing.

    Reply
  13. Olivia Briscoe says

    September 14, 2017 at 9:36 am

    This is a great comparison. Thank you for sharing. I finally finished the Harry Potter series as an adult and love the books so much.

    Reply
  14. Teresa says

    March 11, 2021 at 12:39 am

    I totally agree with what you said and the comparisons you made between Dumbledore’s mercy and Jesus’ mercy. I am happy to find another Catholic Harry Potter fan. As a young Catholic teenager, I appreciate your insights on The Harry Potter series. Although it is a secular series, I agree that it has many Catholic themes.

    Reply

Trackbacks

  1. Elizabeth Glass Turner ~ The Narrative of Evil - Wesleyan Accent says:
    November 14, 2015 at 12:30 pm

    […] We are not at the mercy of terrorists. They are at our mercy as we live in flesh and blood and bone the loving mercy of Jesus Christ, Emmanuel-God-With-Us, who was and is and is to come. As the orange-suited martyrs cried to Jesus on their sandy beach deathbeds, evil crumpled. They have no power over Jesus Christ, they have no power over the world to come, they have no power over your soul.  […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Contact

haley@carrotsformichaelmas.com

Sign Up for My Newsletter!

More ideas about celebrating the liturgical year, free printables, great links I love, and more of the Carrots family in your inbox!



Welcome! I’m Haley Stewart, a bookish mama of four and wife to a beekeeper. Writer, speaker, podcaster, and Catholic convert. Homeschooling, bacon-eating, and bright red lipstick-wearing Jane Austen aficionado. My first book, The Grace of Enough: Pursuing Less and Living More in a Throwaway Culture is available now!

All rights reserved. ©Haley Stewart Unauthorized usage and duplication of text and images without the express permission of Haley and Carrots for Michaelmas is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links to posts may be used as long as clear credit is given to Haley/Carrots for Michaelmas.
Follow on Bloglovin
follow us in feedly

Recent Posts

  • Let’s Support Pregnant Moms and Babies!
  • My New Book! Jane Austen’s Genius Guide to Life
  • Let’s go to the UK this summer!
  • Join me in supporting Haitian women!
  • Big Life Changes for the Stewarts!

Archives

Disclosure

Some links found in my posts are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through an affiliate link, I will receive a percentage of the sale at no additional cost to you. Thank you for helping me support my family and keep the lights on here at Carrots! Haley Stewart is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.
Privacy Policy

Copyright Carrots for Michaelmas © 2023 · Design and Development by Santa Clara Design · Log in